You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
It is likely the division errors in the from_ace routine
I believe there is an issue with the data converted from the LANL MCNP eprdata14 ACE file.
This affects ENDF7.x LANL libraries https://openmc.org/lanl-data-libraries/
It appears that several of the eprdata14 XS are not being 'leveraged' in OpenMC; in my problem a number of the photons undergo far fewer reactions than with other libraries.
When I convert EPICS2017 myself, EPICS2014 myself and use them with ENDF80 neutron data I get the same answer as with Official release OpenMC ENDF80 np. Which is significantly different than with eprdata14 (using OpenMC official endf80 neutron data).
I have not been able to convert eprdata14 ACE myself, see openmc-dev/openmc#2421
Running the same problem in MCNP6.2 with mcplib84, eprdata14 and jendl50 (EPICS2017) I get the same results in all. No major deviation for eprdata14
I am running OpenMC 0.13.3-dev.
Here are some results with the photon_source test.
Slightly modified (vaccuum conditions, 10 batches, Absorption score), see attached model.zip
<style>
</style>
Type
Data Lib.
Source
Flux
1σ
Abs.
1σ
self
-
EPICS2014
226.084
0.336563
3.08141
0.005001
self
-
EPICS2017
226.001
0.339056
3.08162
0.005027
Official
ENDF80
EPICS2017
226.001
0.339056
3.08162
0.005027
Other
FENDL32
epdl97
225.826
0.259935
3.08422
0.008049
LANL
ENDF7.1
eprdata14 (EPICS2014)
2711710000
2859620
0
0
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Update: These two problems are without a doubt coupled:
https://github.com/openmc-dev/data/issues/81
https://github.com/openmc-dev/openmc/issues/2421
It is likely the division errors in the from_ace routine
I believe there is an issue with the data converted from the LANL MCNP eprdata14 ACE file.
This affects ENDF7.x LANL libraries
https://openmc.org/lanl-data-libraries/
It appears that several of the eprdata14 XS are not being 'leveraged' in OpenMC; in my problem a number of the photons undergo far fewer reactions than with other libraries.
When I convert EPICS2017 myself, EPICS2014 myself and use them with ENDF80 neutron data I get the same answer as with Official release OpenMC ENDF80 np. Which is significantly different than with eprdata14 (using OpenMC official endf80 neutron data).
I have not been able to convert eprdata14 ACE myself, see openmc-dev/openmc#2421
Running the same problem in MCNP6.2 with mcplib84, eprdata14 and jendl50 (EPICS2017) I get the same results in all. No major deviation for eprdata14
I am running OpenMC 0.13.3-dev.
Here are some results with the photon_source test.
<style> </style>Slightly modified (vaccuum conditions, 10 batches, Absorption score), see attached model.zip
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: