Notes are missing and return error 500

[tordans]

URL

https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/3533103

How to reproduce the issue?

A

1. Open https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/3533103
2. ==> Error 500, should be a node

B

1. Open https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/3540073#map=17/52.47257/13.43322&layers=N
2. ==> Should have more than 1 open node

API returns one https://www.openstreetmap.org/api/0.6/notes.json?bbox=13.429101705551147,52.47160590360475,13.440345525741579,52.47378871279819

It looks like, only notes created recently are visible, but older active notes are not.

---

FYI @SupaplexOSM

Screenshot(s) or anything else?

No response

[tordans]

Update: This App shows the node https://ent8r.github.io/NotesReview/?view=map&map=16%2F52.4728%2F13.4338&bbox=13.4188%2C52.4705%2C13.4488%2C52.4751&apply-bbox=true&status=all&anonymous=hide

But clicking on "open on osm org" results in the error above.

[tordans]

Update 2:

It looks like this might be two issue…

1

The node above is created by a user account that was not supposed to do anything than hold OSMCha filter. This account is currently blocked. osmberlin_changeset_review. So this is the blocked-user-node-broken issue (a Duplicate).

NOW the node is visible, because Supaplex030 commented…

2

But we also have JS Errors Uncaught TypeError: Cannot read properties of undefined (reading 'text'). At this point the API response in the inspector showed about 10 notes for my bbox but only one was visible.

[tordans]

Update 3:

Now all is visible again. No JS Errors.

Super weird, I will close this for now …

[AntonKhorev]

This is not going to get fixed because #3831

[tomhughes]

This will be a duplicate of #2146 and #3831 is the plan for fixing it - the first part (#3911) was merged this week.

[AntonKhorev]

js errors are fixed in #3617 but fixing them is not part of plans because "The output of the API has to remain the same for now"

[gravitystorm]

fixing them is not part of plans

That's not true.

[AntonKhorev]

That's not true.

Are you going to change the API, like adding a guarantee that there's at least one comment per note?