Results when comparing to pymedphys.gamma

[SimonBiggs]

Hi @samuelpeet,

I have been meaning to run a comparison of flashgamma to pymedphys.gamma for quite some time. Anyway, I worked through it this morning using the example files you provided at:

• https://raw.githubusercontent.com/samuelpeet/flashgamma/c00f388856cd3651b706a7b117ff90930aa5ee54/examples/sample_snc_extracted_data.snc
• https://raw.githubusercontent.com/samuelpeet/flashgamma/master/examples/sample_arccheck_measurement.txt

If you're interested I have uploaded the results into the following zip:

compare_to_flash_gamma.zip

Cheers,
Simon

[SimonBiggs]

So that the results can be seen within the GitHub issue (without needing to download the zip), here is what flash gamma presented:

and here is PyMedPhys' results for the same dataset:

It would be interesting to be able to get to the bottom of the discrepancy...